Free

Euthanasia: comparative analysis - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Euthanasia is today once again being debated and these two articles present arguments for and against it. While Sidney Hook takes a suffering patient's point of view in In Defense of Voluntary Euthanasia, Singer and Siegler take the standpoint of the medical practitioner in Euthanasia - A Critique.
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
Euthanasia: comparative analysis
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Euthanasia: comparative analysis"

Euthanasia is today once again being debated and these two articles present arguments for and against it. While Sidney Hook takes a suffering patient's point of view in In Defense of Voluntary Euthanasia, Singer and Siegler take the standpoint of the medical practitioner in Euthanasia - A Critique.
Hook's style is more personal, full of emotion, and in the first person, befitting a person speaking from harrowing experience on the topic. Singer and Siegler adopt a more formal and impersonal style for the presentation of their arguments, and their approach is guided by a holistic perspective of the medical profession in general, and the role of doctors in alleviating patient suffering in particular.
Being a philosopher, Hook's language is a bit pedantic, and his sentences a little roundabout. His writing conventions, though impeccable for his times, are a bit archaic, as he belongs to the old school of writing. The other article written by a collaboration of the younger Singer and Siegler is more straightforward, and to the point, the sentences are shorter and easier to understand.
With regard to the arguments, both the articles first present a rebuttal of their claims, and then go on to present qualifiers, but the difference lies in the number of times this exercise is carried out. In the case of Hook, he presents a rebuttal only once, early in the article, by relating his experience where his suffering had led him to ask for euthanasia, which was denied and all turned out well. In the other article, Singer and Siegler present evidence and a series of rebuttals, points in justification of euthanasia, for example the case of Netherlands. They then systematically nullify these by their qualifiers, like why a similar policy will not be successful in America, or even that it is perhaps not completely successful in Netherlands. In the second case the sheer number of rebuttals negated drives the point home.
Another significant difference lies in the evidence presented in both the articles. The only concrete piece of evidence provided by Hook is his near-death trauma, whereas Singer and Siegler, present an entire battery of evidence from various documents cited. They start with the example of Netherlands and also provide deductive reasoning on how effective pain management, or voluntary removal of life support can make euthanasia redundant, and that public policy should not allow the right to euthanasia on the grounds of possible misuse.
Most of Hook's assumptions are implicit, for instance about another possible heart attack, the probable suffering of his kin and his age disallowing him to achieve anything further. They are also personal, and will not hold universally, as age is a factor particular to him, and may not be common with all other patients. And as he himself admits, the desire to live on at whatever cost is not uncommon. On the other hand, most of the assumptions made by the other article are explicit, and are not limited in their premise. Singer and Siegler provide precise definitions and technical reasons why and how euthanasia can actually become harmful to society.
These articles making the claim for and against the case of euthanasia are equally strong and adequately present the two different points of view. The essential difference is that what compels reader attention for Hook is his voice emerging from genuine suffering, whereas Singer and Siegler derive their power purely on the basis of sound logic, and an unshakeable faith in the medical profession as a giver, and not a taker of life.
Work Cited
Hook, Sidney "In Defense of Voluntary Euthanasia" - Read, Reason, Write: An
Argument Text and Reader. 7th ed. Dorothy U. Seyler. Boston: MacGrawHill, 2205. 109-111
Singer, Peter A., and Mark Siegler. "Euthanasia - A Critique." Read, Reason, Write: An Argument Text and Reader. 7th ed. Dorothy U. Seyler. Boston: MacGrawHill, 2205. 112-113 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Euthanasia: comparative analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Euthanasia: comparative analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1528669-euthanasia-comparative-analysis
(Euthanasia: Comparative Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Euthanasia: Comparative Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1528669-euthanasia-comparative-analysis.
“Euthanasia: Comparative Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1528669-euthanasia-comparative-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Euthanasia: comparative analysis

Comparative Analysis

...FHM and Cosmopolitan: A Comparative Analysis on Gendered Lifestyle Magazines Gender is commonly defined as a biological difference in the sexes. However, Eckert and McConnell-Ginet (10) maintains that gender is also perceived in terms of sexuality, sexual identity and desire that sexualizes traits and objects associated with masculinity and femininity. Because of this, gender difference is normatively used as a basis of heterosexual pull in literary works such as personality development books and lifestyle magazines. Some are themed according to the gender of the target reader population to specifically accommodate their needs and preferences in terms of individuality, career, relationships and sexuality...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Comparative Analysis

...Module Comparative Analysis “The Story of an Hour” and “A Rose for Emily” Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” and William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” both exemplifies the nature of marriage in a woman’s perspective through the choice of women characters as protagonists. The protagonists in the two stories i.e. Louise Mallard in “The Story of an Hour” and Emily Grierson in “A Rose for Emily” exhibit both similarities and differences. Their similarity is based to the fact they both lived in similar ideological periods and experienced the same developmental patterns. Their main difference is related to their goals and the way in which they thought they could achieve them. SIMILARITIES The protagonists in...
5 Pages(1250 words)Book Report/Review

Comparative analysis

...?Client’s 10 October The Road Not Taken Robert Frost needs no introduction; he was a great American poet who wrote very popular poems. His poems on rustic life of people have gained popularity and several of his poems have an allegoric meaning. His use of language in his poems was immaculate; this paper will shed some light upon his very popular poem called The Road not Taken. The main focus of this paper will be upon important factors such as symbols, rhyme scheme, figures of speech so on and so forth. This poem is a very deep poem, one has to read it over and over again to understand its hidden meaning. Life is really complicated and we need to understand our aim and to do that we need to sit down and introspect. Many a time we... 10...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Comparative analysis

...?Comparative Analysis of the Paintings of Giotto and Michelangelo This essay shall compare the works of two prominent Italian artists whose works areimmortalized in the Sistine Chapel and the Arena Chapel. Specifically, Giotto di Bondone’s, “Last Judgment” and Michelangelo Buonarroti’s “The Fall and Expulsion from Garden of Eden” have been selected to be analyzed. Both represent endpoints in the bible…. Michelangelo’s from the beginning of man and Giotto’s as the end of his journey on earth. It is interesting how in each painting, two scenarios are portrayed. It is such a wonder that both artists were able to visualize in their rich imagination the vivid images of events which are not of their present time. While both paintings... Analysis of ...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Comparative analysis

...? Sarah Cole: A Type of Love Story 'Love story' is a usual topic to create a story about. In fact, love is an element that emerges in nearly every work of art; love songs, paintings with half-nude man and woman, poems that cry for lost or hopefully, beginning love, novels needless to say, and sculptures. Yet, not many of these overtly explain that the contents are about love, for example by incorporating the word 'love' in their titles. Well-known love stories, such as 'Titanic', 'Romeo and Juliet' and 'Phantom of the Opera' have names, which do not directly say 'love' (Ryu). This way we don't realize if the story is about the voyage of a cruise ship or a conflict between two people or a horror story of an opera house. Just like... Sarah...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Comparative Analysis

...John Stewart Mill, in the 19th century, laid the finishing touches on the edifice of ethical theory en d utilitarianism. Utilitarianism, a form of consequentialist normative theory, became a dominant force in moral discourse shortly thereafter. To this day, it competes with Kantianism as the dominant position amongst professional philosophers on how to speak about actions and their moral qualities. In contrast to Kantian deontology, utilitarianism evaluates acts in the context of their consequences and whether they maximize people’s utility or not. In environmental discourse, utilitarianism has become a dominant paradigm. Philosophers like Peter Singer have adopted utilitarian viewpoints in order to justify a strongly favorable... Stewart...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Comparative analysis

...………………………………………………….. D. Infrastructure development (Transportation facilities): Gold Coast and Sunshine Coast…... IV. Findings……………………………………………………………………………………….8 V. Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………..9 VI. References……………………………………………………………………………………10 VII. Appendices………………………………………………………………………………….11 Comparative analysis I. Introduction Generally saying, behind every tourist hotspot, one can expect the rich history of planning and creativity of a few blessed minds. Worldwide, coastal areas, especially sea coasts with wide beaches attract millions of national and international tourists. As international tourism is blooming, the Gold Coast...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Comparative Analysis

...Comparative Analysis of the Psychology of the Concerned August 24, Comparative Analysis Schizophrenia is mostly characterized by a severing of contact with the realities of life, usually addressed as psychosis (Butcher, 2002). I believe that Alice is suffering from schizophrenia. If one delves into epidemiology aspects of schizophrenia, the incidence of schizophrenia is more common in people affiliated to low socio-economic status as the patients usually tend to drift down the socio-economic scale before the symptoms of schizophrenia get manifested (Gill, 2007, p. 42)). The disheveled and unkempt state of Alice is indicative of this. As per the opinion held by DSM-IV-TR,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Comparative analysis

...Comparative Analysis Transcript analysis of non-model plants is the method through which many of the contemporary research in plants and various living matter uses to understand the various characteristics in these living products. The method is imperative because it ensures that there is specification of the particular product. An example is the fact that through transcript analysis, there is the assurance of identification of a specific epidermis. The epidermis of plants varies but it is imperative to understand that the normal or scientific microscope does not carry out effective work of determining the difference in plants of a similar species. Transcript...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Comparative Analysis

...Comparative analysis Children of the Sea” by Edwidge Danticat and “Big Mamas Funeral” by Gabriel Garcia Marquez) Course name University Date Comparative analysis (“Children of the Sea” by Edwidge Danticat and “Big Mamas Funeral” by Gabriel Garcia Marquez) Contemporary literature does not stop to astonish the readers of any circle and mentality. The diversity of genres and variety of techniques impress entirely. Modern reader has a chance to choose such piece of literary art that he/she likes and appreciate. There is a tendency in postmodern culture to deem that everything has already written and done. People cannot create anything new; still we observe a wide multiplicity of literary works that affect reader’s minds and perception...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Euthanasia: comparative analysis for FREE!

Contact Us