Nobody downloaded yet

Compare and contrast two Management Theories - Term Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The aim of this paper is to compare Douglas McGregor’s theory x and y and Chris Argyris management theory. Douglas McGregor was one of the contributors of neo-human relations theory of organizational humanism. He introduced the contrasting concept of Theory X and Theory Y that are based on assumptions about work and people. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Compare and contrast two Management Theories
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Compare and contrast two Management Theories"

Download file to see previous pages Theory X
This theory is based on traditional conception of control and direction. The theory makes assumptions that average human beings do not like working. Because of this dislike, most people must be punished in order to put forth adequate effort towards the realization of the organization’s goals. Furthermore, theory X assumes that average people prefer to be directed, wish to avoid responsibility, have relatively little ambitions and want securities (Sapru, 2006).
Traditionally, this theory was referred to as the carrot and the stick theory and was practically based on mechanistic approach to human relations. Rewards and punishments may be used to induce desired behavior, and this came from the donkey story whereby the best way to make a donkey move was to "put a carrot in front of the donkey or jab him with a stick from behind" (Sapru, 2006). Rewards and punishments are still strong motivators in many organizations.
The use of theory X works well under certain circumstances; however, this does not work at all once an employee has attained the highest level and is motivated by higher needs. In other words, this theory does not explain human nature. McGregor states that as long as theory X continues to influence managerial strategy, human potentialities cannot be discovered.
Theory Y
The inadequacies in theory X led to development of theory Y as integration to replace traditional concepts of direction and control. The human motivations in theory Y may be characterized by the expenditure of physical and mental effort in work. Here, an ordinary person does not dislike work (Miner, 2007). ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare and contrast two Management Theories Term Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1595460-compare-and-contrast-two-management-theories
(Compare and Contrast Two Management Theories Term Paper)
https://studentshare.org/management/1595460-compare-and-contrast-two-management-theories.
“Compare and Contrast Two Management Theories Term Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1595460-compare-and-contrast-two-management-theories.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare and contrast two Management Theories

Compare/contrast three counseling theories

...? Comparison and Contrasting of Three Counseling Theories: Cognitive-Behavioral, Person-Centered and Gestalt Therapy BY YOU YOUR SCHOOL INFO HERE YOUR TUTOR HERE DATE HERE Cognitive-Behavioral, Person-Centered and Gestalt Therapy Cognitive-behavioral therapy is a form of social learning that is facilitated in direct interventions and communications between therapist and patient related closely to social learning theory (Reilly & Shopshire, 2002). This therapy style often utilizes operant conditioning, a form of behavior change that is reinforced through reward methodology (Morris & Maisto, 2005). For example, if the patient has deviant behaviors created through hostility and aggression,...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Compare and Contrast of Two Personality Theories

...in their assumptions and view on human psychology, which undermines or improves the effectiveness of each in psychology (Schmidt and Schmidt, 1983). This essay aims to compare and contrast the Rogers and Freud theories, which are the writer’s most favorite and least favorite theories respectively. The essay will conclude by describing the most effective personality theory combination. Comparison Similarities First, it is pertinent to note that these theories are similar in their foundations, in that both are based on similar basic assumptions, and depend on observation of basic phenomena in day-to-day life. However, this is also the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Compare and Contrast Two Movies

...Compare and contrast two movies The film Amelie by Jean Pierre talks about a young lady who acts as a shy waitress in France city of Paris. The lady has dedicated most of her life in helping the people around her, to improve their lives despite the problems she faces in isolation. The film informs us about how she lost her parents, and because of these become forced into some isolation. This enabled her posses an active mind that managed to keep her of the isolation thoughts. She helps a man who works as a painter reunite back with his family. She also manages to help the man retrieve a childhood box that was full of his memories. She...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Compare and Contrast 2 Quality Management Theories

...In contrast to Six Sigma, lean techniques rely on process improvement through an investigation of the workflows. Compared to Six Sigma, lean techniques stand a better chance at quality management in the health care sector. Research has proven that lean techniques tend to produce a better framework for quality management in the healthcare sector (Babensky, Roe, & Bolton, 2005). As mentioned before, quality management in the healthcare sector is concerned in large part with supporting processes such as resource allocation, scheduling, workflow improvements etc. so it makes more sense to bring in lean techniques since they focus on these process...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Compare and contrast two articles

...the implications on interpretive philosophies. It investigates the values and beliefs in the context of social sciences developed by intellectuals such as Peter Winch and Max Weber. The objectives of these works are comparative research in criminal justice. It addresses the definitive meaning personality of human activities. However, unlike postmodernism and constructivism this theory pays attribute to the disposition and goals of institutional realities. Therefore, the principle of this assignment is to compare and contrast the presentations of the two authors with close reference to methods and findings applied in each of the documents. It is easy for...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Compare or Contrast two buildings

... Planning Page Compare and contrast two buildings 2. U.S General Services Administration Building and Ariel Rios Federal Building 3. U.S General Services Administration Building and Ariel Rios Federal Building showcase massive architecture, uncluttered appearance and subtle artistic design comparing two samples of America’s Neo-Classical architecture. 4. Brain Storm List I. Massive Architecture. A. U.S General Services Administration Building’s E-shaped configuration. B. Ariel Rios Federal Building Semi-circular facade. II. Uncluttered Appearance. A. U.S General Services Administration Building’s organized flat and long facade. B. Ariel Rios Federal Building’s sweeping facade. III. Subtle Artistic Design. A. U.S General Services... ...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Compare and contrast two leaders

...Gandhi Vs Hitler Personal biography and social context Twentieth century dawned to create two eminent leaders in the political scenario of Germany and India, who still attracts appreciation as well as criticism from historians, and rational thinkers. Autobiography of Mohandas Gandhi and Adolph Hitler are worth reading to get a clear picture of anarchy prevalent in their respective nations during the onset of 20th century. Gandhi is the best known theorist and practitioner of nonviolent action, who developed his distinctive theory of ‘Satyagraha’ or truth force, and success of the movement for Indian independence, which augmented its acceptance worldwide. Hitler was instrumental in German Nationalist movement, who is accused... surrender. He...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Compare and Contrast Two Theories of Motivation

...Motivation Compare and Contrast Two Theories of Motivation The Motivation of employees has always been perceived as a means for an organization, not only to survive, but also thrive. There is a general feeling that employees, who are motivated, are more productive. Given the present results, managers are currently trying to comprehend what makes these workers motivated and hence more productive. There are two theories that this paper endeavors to focus on: The first one is Abraham Maslow’s “Hierarchy of Five Needs” theory and the second one is McGregor’s Theory X and Y. Dating back into...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

COMPARE AND CONTRAST TWO POEMS

...Two Poems: Advice to Our Sons Langston Hughes’ “Mother to Son” and Peter Meinke’s “Advice to My Son” work well as a means to compare and contrast varying societal conditions and viewpoints regarding life’s trials and challenges. While both poems share some similarities regarding content, each express their viewpoint in very different ways. Told in a conversational tone, Hughes’ poem shares a mother’s constant concern that life is a precarious experience. When she states that “Life for me ain’t no crystal stair” (Hughes line 2), the mother conveys to her son not only the rough obstacles she has experienced, but also puts forward a warning regarding what he will face throughout...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Compare and Contrast Two Readings

...Compare and Contrast The Susan Bordo article richly discusses the male body form as seen advertisements – a theme which is akin to the rediscovery of the male form amidst the seeming obsessive preoccupation on the female form. The article turns its attention on the sexuality of the male form, including its general appeal to the population. It specifies the revolutionary portrayal of the male highly sexual form through underwear advertisements like that of Calvin Klein. Where the portrayal in the past was muted in its sexuality, such sexuality now seems to be the running theme in these advertisements. These advertisements also present men as sexual objects, in much the same way as women have often been...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Term Paper on topic Compare and contrast two Management Theories for FREE!

Contact Us