Nobody downloaded yet

Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Government on the Adult Non-Smokers of Scotland - Thesis Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper focused on the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Government on the Adult Non-Smokers of Scotland. The paper funded by NHS Health Scotland and the Scottish Executive, Sally J Haw and Laurence Gruer…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Government on the Adult Non-Smokers of Scotland
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Government on the Adult Non-Smokers of Scotland"

Download file to see previous pages The researchers successfully deal with the comprehensiveness of the topic of their study. Though previous researches on the air quality of the public places of Scotland refer to the subsequent impact of the smoke-free legislation, their acute limitation was that they do not tell much about the impacts on the private places. Haw and Gruer’s comprehensive approach to the research topic pertinently includes the exposure of non-smokers in private places. Such a comprehensive approach to the changes in exposure aids the readers to achieve an overall picture of the change in exposure.

Another thing is remarkable that the researchers are more concerned to prove the consistency of the findings of their paper with other studies than to clarify the concepts of “exposure to second-hand smoke” (Haw & Gruer, 2007: 549) and the parameters of “change” that they are dealing in the paper. Significantly their paper lacks an efficient literature review that could have clarified the outline of their research topic and another related concept. Also, it lacks a sufficient literature review to support its methodology and other approaches to the research topic.

Appropriateness and Validity of Methodology. Haw and Gruer do not tell anything about ethical approval by an ethics committee. Also, they do not describe the maintenance of ethical issues for the paper. As to the research method, Haw and Gruer chose the cross-sectional approach for their research. But the flaw within their methodological approach is that though in the first place they chose the cross-sectional method, they used longitudinal data also. Though they expressed the aim of the study as “to measure the change in adult non-smokers’ exposure to secondhand smoke in public and private places after smoke-free legislation was implemented in Scotland” (Haw & Gruer, 2007: 549), they failed to clarify the dichotomy between longitudinal and cross-sectional changes in exposure. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Go Thesis, n.d.)
Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Go Thesis. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1559900-critical-evaluation
(Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Go Thesis)
Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Go Thesis. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1559900-critical-evaluation.
“Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Go Thesis”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1559900-critical-evaluation.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Government on the Adult Non-Smokers of Scotland

Impacts of the Secondhand Smoke

...to reduce secondhand smoke exposure among young children are clearly called. Reducing secondhand smoke exposure is indeed a public health challenge that remains in the coming decades. Governments around the world have limited the hazards of second-hand smoke (SHS) through legislation to ensure smoke-free workplaces (Fernandez, Fu, Pascual et al. 1). However a lot needs to be done to protect young children from SHS. To reduce the ETS exposure among children, there is a need to educate parents about dangers of secondhand smoke for their children and to increase efforts to reduce the ETS exposure among...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Critical Evaluation

... From The Damned Human Race by Mark Twain In Mark Twain’s The Damned Human Race attempts to disapprove Darwin theory which claims that human being beings ascended from the lower animals. In Mark Twain’s opinion, man is the one who descended from the lower animal and is thus lesser that all the lower animals. Twains argument is not successful but is flawed. On the contrary, Darwin’s theory, which places human as the highest and of all animals, is correct. Man is capable of reasoning, showing empathy to both his own species and others. This research paper will critically analyze Mark Twain’s The Damned Human Race and will discuss the fallacies that make the arguments unsuccessful. One of Twains argument to disapprove Darwin’s theory...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Copyright Legislation Impacts on GIS

...Copyright Impacts on GIS users Professional Life Copyright Legislation Impacts on GIS Users Professional Life Farzeela Copyright Copyright protection has been in existence in one form or another for hundreds of years to protect original work from being copied without the prior consent of the creator of the work. In UK, the current copyright legislation is based upon the Copyright, Designs and Patent Act 1988, as well as referring back to the 1956 and 1911 Acts in specific circumstances. The legislation has also been supplemented by subsequent Directives derived from Europe and international conventions and treaties. Recent changes in...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Nation to Be Smoke-Free

...AAP (2007, 6 Sept Call for nation to be smoke free in 10 years. Sydney Morning Herald. Several health organizations in Australia are agitating forthe passage of anti-smoking legislature, designed to transform Australia into a smoke-free country within a decade. Pointing to the example of New Zealand, the campaigners contend that the proposal is not at all unrealistic and that federal and state governmental commitment can realise the identified objective. The transformation of Australia into a smoke-free society cannot be realised without the backing of both the public and legislators. It entails the...
13 Pages(3250 words)Article

Critical Evaluation

...Response to Review of Anita Pacheco’s ‘Royalism and honor in Aphra Behn’s Oroonoko’ The critical review of Anita Pacheco’s ‘Royalism and honor in Aphra Behn’s Oroonoko’ clearly identifies the central thesis – “that the ideology of [Oroonoko] is royalist and also that its effort at ‘ideological closure’ is undermined by its continuity with the historical period and by its reliance on an unstable discourse of honor” -- made by Pacheco in her essay; however, fails to examine or evaluate the contents of the text in full vis-à-vis her thesis to understand or guide the prospective readers as to how Pacheco fares in establishing her thesis. Focusing too much on Pacheco’s argument that Behn’s novella is...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Smokers vs. non-smokers

..., but not with diagnoses of these outcomes. This study provided an evidence for the extensive exposure to ETS among adult nonsmokers in Syria, and its dose-response relationship with respiratory symptoms of infectious and noninfectious nature. It also called for an elaborate effort to increase awareness of this public health problem and to enforce regulations aimed at protecting non-smokers. Oncken et al (2002) evaluated the effect of repeated cigarette smoking on fetal heart rate (FHR) characteristics. Their observation in this study indicated that cigarette smoking has a significant impact on FHR...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Smoke-free campus

... Smoke Free-Campus Tobacco products had posed a substantial problem the of Texas located at San Antonio. The administration had keenly observed how students, staff, and support staff had been addicted to smoking and this was affecting even the non-smokers. Research conducted United States where the university is located had shown that lung cancer caused by cigarette smoking accounted for 30% of the total deaths in the region (Reznicek 72). Additionally, many deaths had occurred because of inhaling secondhand smoke. According to the university’s operation procedures outlined in a handbook, cigarette smoke was hazardous to the environment and a health risk, which called for an attempt to make the university a tobacco-free area... the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Insurance Premiums and Smoke Free Environment

...premiums have continued to rise; and eventuality that places an undue level of stress on the business and upon the employees. However, rather than merely raising the premiums across the board for all individuals in the company, it has been determined that a far more equitable and fair approach would be to raise healthcare premiums by 15% for those individuals smoke stop the underlying reason for this is not to target a specific group of people; instead, it is meant as a way of fairly representing the healthcare costs that the insurer, and by extension this company, is forced to pay. Further understanding with regards to the impacts of smoke and secondhand smoke reveals...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Smokers

...administration has a responsibility of protecting this generation. In an attempt to protect the whole population, these governments have come up with several measures that are aimed at reducing the exposure of the people to this kind of smoke (Callinan, Clarke & Kelleher 2010) The number of smokers in these countries is smaller compared to non-smokers. As a result, the governments are protecting the majority of the population through developing various strategies that will reduce the impact of cigarette smoke on the people. The smokers should stay outside the homes, restaurants and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Is the Media Leading Non-smokers to Smoke in The United States

...is not free from necessary or unnecessary tensions. In order to relax or to make the mind free from the agitating thoughts, people often have a tendency to get addicted to something and smoking is the simplest form of relaxation techniques most of the people adopt. The heavy expenditure on tobacco ads by the tobacco companies encourages people to use their products. Most of the governments have banned ads without the warning signals; but such warnings will never reach the non-smokers or smokers because of the least importance such things have while displaying tobacco ads. Tobacco companies are producing ads for promoting...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Thesis on topic Critical Evaluation of the Impacts of Smoke-Free Legislation of the Government on the Adult Non-Smokers of Scotland for FREE!

Contact Us